That's 37 points higher than the homeowners insurance segment average for 2023. Home Study.ĮRIE earned the highest homeowners insurance ranking of all rank-eligible property and casualty (P&C) carriers with a score of 856 on J.D. 1 in both homeowners and renters insurance business lines, according to the J.D. 19, 2023 /PRNewswire/ - Erie Insurance ( ERIE) is the best in home insurance customer satisfaction, ranking No. Study finds ERIE is best in customer satisfaction for both homeowners and renters insuranceĮRIE, Pa., Dec.